News

Study claims GMO cancer risk
Enlarge image

PolicyEUUKFranceSpain

Study claims GMO cancer risk

21.09.2012 - Researchers from the organisation Criigen have published a GMO feeding study suggesting a cancer risk in mice. Critics say the study design was not appropriate.

In the peer reviewed journal Food and Chemical Toxicology a team headed by Criigen president Gilles-Eric Seralini report that lab mice fed with Monsanto’s GM maize NK603 or with the herbicide Glyphosate developed faster tumours than control mice. While treated female rats died 2-3 fold more frequently than controls, male rats which received the GMO or herbicide diet over 2 years developed tumours, which were up to 4 times larger than in control mice and occurred earlier in their life cycle, accompanied by kidney defects in both sexes.

However, critics questioned the credibility and reliability of the data. "The methods, stats and reporting of results are all well below the standard I would expect in a rigorous study – to be honest I am surprised it was accepted for publication“, stated Prof. Dr. David Spiegelhalter from University of Cambridge, UK, explaining that there was no full data set, no relevant number of animals involved to demonstrate statistical significance and no dose-dependent effect confirming the conclusions of the study authors. Prof. Dr. Maurice Moloney, chief of Rothamsted Research, pointed to the fact that the rat species used by the French researchers is extremely susceptible to developing spontaneous cancers, with up to 86% in wild-type males and 72% in normal females. According to Dr. Wendy Harwood, John Innes Centre, „without access to the full data, we can only say that these results cannot be interpreted as showing that GM technology itself is dangerous.“ Some researchers also criticised that it was not good scientific practice to give the data to the press before making them public to the scientific community. Others such as Prof. Dr. Jose Miquel Mulet from University of Valencia presumed the study was politically motivated: The reports of Criigen are put forward by the French authorities as justification to maintaining bans on cultivating GMOs,“he stressed. French Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault stated in Paris: "The government is keeping its moratorium on the cultivation of GMO seeds currently authorised in the European Union." 

A spokesman of the European Food watchdog EFSA said it will consider the paper’s relevance (http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/press/news/120919b.htm). The study appears as a direct attack on the EFSA’s methods. However, recently, an independent study carried out by Ernst & Young confirmed the agency’s assessments had excellent scientific quality.  

Since the foundation of Criigen in 2001, its researchers have questioned the design of animal studies used to assess GMO safety. The organisation is financed through contract research . Although its researchers carry out contract studies for Greenpeace and Carrefour, the large French food retailer which claims its products to be GM-free, its researchers say the organisation is independent.

© eurobiotechnews.eu/tg

FundingEU

17.04.2014 The European Parliament has given green light to the second Innovative Medicines Initiative with the aim to advance pharmacological research and development, particularly in areas of unmet medical need.

BusinessGermanyFrance

15.04.2014 German flavour and scent specialist Symrise has announced its plans to acquire French pet-food ingredients maker Diana Group for €1.3bn.

BioeconomySpain

14.04.2014 Spanish Neol Biosolutions and the Center for Second Generation Biofuels are starting a partnership to scale-up Neol's waste-to-oil technology.

EvidenceUKSwitzerland

11.04.2014 There is no evidence that neuraminidase inhibitors Tamiflu and Relenza prevent complications of influenza or reduce hospital admissions. In addition, it is unclear whether they can stop the spread of influenza in case of outbreaks, says a report by the Cochrane Collaboration.

BusinessSwitzerlandSpain

09.04.2014 Roche is extending its involvement in the area of point-of-care diagnostics by taking over US company Iquum. In the field of epigenetics, the Swiss pharma company has started a cooperation with the Spanish company Oryzon.

Status ReportSwitzerland

08.04.2014 The Swiss Biotech Report 2014 presented in Zurich sees an encouraging upturn in the country's biotech scene. However, the acceptance of the mass immigration initiative poses a significant threat.

NanobiotechnologyItaly

07.04.2014 Scientists from the University of Udine have designed, produced and tested a prototype for a "DNA origami" nanorobot that can potentially deliver biological activators in-vivo.

EpidemicEUFranceGermanyItaly

02.04.2014 As the Ebola epidemic in Guinea worsens, Europe is deploying the specialists of EMLab to provide diagnostics at the focus of the outbreak.

BioeconomyFranceEU

01.04.2014 The European Commission has approved a French state package aid worth €43m for green chemistry project IEED.

MonitoringEU

27.03.2014 In Europe, bacterial resistance to prevalent antimicrobials is common, while multi-resistance remains low, EFSA and ECDC now report.

Events

All Events

Partner-Events

München

BioVaria 2014

Frankfurt am Main

7th DVFA Life Science Conference

Current issue

All issues

Product of the week

Products

Stock list

All quotes

TOP

  • PHARMING (NL)0.53 EUR12.8%
  • BAVARIAN NORDIC (D)14.56 EUR10.3%
  • NICOX (F)2.44 EUR7.5%

FLOP

  • XENETIC BIOSCIENCES (UK)6.00 GBP-14.3%
  • GENFIT (F)22.42 EUR-8.1%
  • DEINOVE (F)12.96 EUR-5.3%

TOP

  • BIOTECH PHARMACON (N)17.50 NOK59.1%
  • WILEX (D)0.92 EUR53.3%
  • E-THERAPEUTICS (UK)28.00 GBP40.0%

FLOP

  • CYTOS (CH)0.17 CHF-93.8%
  • BIONOR PHARMA (N)2.11 NOK-44.9%
  • PROTHENA PLC (IE)28.07 USD-40.8%

TOP

  • SILENCE THERAPEUTICS (UK)256.00 GBP6221.0%
  • IXICO (UK)71.50 GBP810.8%
  • PHARMING (NL)0.53 EUR783.3%

FLOP

  • CYTOS (CH)0.17 CHF-95.8%
  • EVOCUTIS (UK)0.22 GBP-92.5%
  • AGENNIX (D)0.04 EUR-77.8%

No liability assumed, Date: 19.04.2014