Politics / Law

Heard in Brussels: Keeping it local – be afraid of the CJEU

06.03.2012

Brussels – In February, I heard of a slightly mad and very worrying trend in decisions handed down by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) with regard to IP issues handed up from the national level for clarification. IP is not very exciting to start with, but the more you understand about the situation developing, the more you see Europe backing itself into a corner about something that could have major ramifications for commercialisation of technologies.
It all started with IP for antibodies. As everyone in the industry knows, antibodies are incredibly complicated items in terms of IP – with a product that cannot be pinned to the wall accurately, and with post-translation modification and environmental factors influencing structure, activity and effect. This leads to long development times in groundbreaking regulatory and IP arenas. The supplementary protection certificate (SPC) in theory gives 5.5 years of extension beyond the original patent duration, and this has been used by a number of organisations to enable effective biological products to be protected to market. Of course, this is a very challenging area of IP, which was not designed to include biological entities, and which refers strongly to the regulations of the original patent. Increasingly, national patent offices are referring tricky cases to the CJEU for clarification, and this is where the wheels are coming off – with very serious consequences for the European commercial environment.Instead of casting light into the darkness, aside from a few notable decisions, the CJEU has instead returned slow, lengthy and impenetrable decisions that make it nearly impossible to make a national decision to grant an SPC. Clarification has been requested but actively avoided by the court, a great example being reference to ‘non-European rules governing patents’ but without actually saying which ones, even when asked a straight question on the matter.
National authorities are unable to interpret the legal way forward. “I am bound to say that I find this reasoning difficult to follow,” says Lord Justice Arnold, and “not only has the Court not answered the question referred, but also the guidance it has provided is not sufficiently clear to enable future disputes to be resolved”.
Translation: it would seem that Europe has knitted itself a time-bomb for extending protection of biological products. The CJEU, through either a profound lack of understanding of the issues or through wilful incompetence, is preventing the successful exploitation of next-generation therapeutics, and can’t be touched.
The price will be paid by European companies trying to develop products, by researchers who have dedicated years to the innovation behind bio­logicals and of course by the patients, who may wait much longer for a groundbreaking therapy. Those products will one day be developed elsewhere and imported into Europe – exactly the opposite of the EC’s drive to create a knowledge-driven economy … and a mess of Europe’s own making.

Politics / Law

06.03.2012

London – The European Medicines Agency (EMA) calls it “the biggest change to the legal framework since the establishment of the Agency in 1995.” This year, the EU drug regulators are preparing new so-called pharmacovigilance...

Clinical Trial

06.03.2012

Norway’s Algeta ASA (Oslo) has updated its Phase III survival analysis of Alpharadin in patients with castration-resistant prostate cancer and bone metastases. The analysis showed an increase of 3.6 months in median overall...

Clinical Trial

06.03.2012

Genticel S.A. (Toulouse) has completed enrolment in its Phase Ib study of a lyophilised version of the world’s very first therapeutic vaccine ProCervix, which inhibits infection with the cancer-causing Human Papilloma Virus. The...

Clinical Trial

06.03.2012

The share value of French specialist for cardiometabolic diseases Genfit S.A. (Loos/Lille) took a jump after the company announced its candidate drug GFT505 had met all efficacy endpoints in a pilot Phase II study involving 22...

Clinical Trial

06.03.2012

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has granted a Biologics License Application (BLA) to the HER2 dimerisation inhibitor pertuzumab developed by Roche (Basel) for previously untreated HER2­-positive metastatic breast...

Politics / Law

06.03.2012

A For years, the world’s major patent offices – including the EPO, USPTO and JPO – have been collaborating in the Patent Prosecution Highway (PPH) programme. Under the PPH, an applicant whose claims have been allowed in one...

BioFunding

06.03.2012

Berlin/Dublin – Two EU initiatives are seeking to better predict response to cancer treatments. Researchers from the a6m RESPONSIFY Project will develop biomarker-based breast cancer prognosis tests that could be used to predict...

BioFunding

06.03.2012

Bremen/Brussels – European researchers kicked-off the MicroB3 (Bio­diversity, Bioinformatics, Biotechnology) project in February. Thanks to a a9m EU fund, the 32 groups involved will create a unique bioinformatic resource that...

BioFunding

06.03.2012

A Brussels – The European Commission is boosting its investments and policy activities to foster sustainability. “Europe needs to make the transition to a post-petroleum economy,” said Máire Geoghegan-Quinn in Brussels. In...

Politics / Law

06.03.2012

The human race is at war with another species, and has been for thousands of years. Each of us in Europe swats dead dozens of the enemy every summer, and in the tropics they kill thousands of people with infectious diseases...

Displaying results 11 to 20 out of 1982

< Previous 11-20 Next >

© 2007-2014 BIOCOM

http://www.european-biotechnology-news.com/nc/news/messages-archive/archive/browse/1/article/heard-in-brusselskeeping-it-local-be-afraid-of-the-cjeu.html

Events

All Events

Stock list

All quotes

TOP

  • PHARMING (NL)0.48 EUR11.63%
  • MDX HEALTH (B)3.80 EUR10.79%
  • NEUROVIVE PHARMACEUTICAL AB (S)70.00 SEK8.53%

FLOP

  • ANTISOMA (UK)1.32 GBP-14.84%
  • XENETIC BIOSCIENCES (UK)6.00 GBP-14.29%
  • NOVACYT (F)4.46 EUR-10.26%

TOP

  • WILEX (D)2.82 EUR231.8%
  • ADDEX (CH)3.80 CHF58.3%
  • NEUROVIVE PHARMACEUTICAL AB (S)70.00 SEK44.9%

FLOP

  • HYBRIGENICS (F)1.72 EUR-29.5%
  • PROSENSA (NL)9.67 USD-23.8%
  • VITA 34 (D)4.18 EUR-20.4%

TOP

  • SANTHERA (CH)59.90 CHF2836.3%
  • GW PHARMACEUTICALS (UK)431.00 GBP676.6%
  • PAION (D)2.42 EUR255.9%

FLOP

  • EVOCUTIS (UK)0.21 GBP-92.6%
  • CYTOS (CH)0.27 CHF-92.0%
  • THROMBOGENICS (B)9.16 EUR-70.4%

No liability assumed, Date: 30.07.2014


Current issue

All issues

Product of the week

Products